Thursday, June 20, 2019

With respect to Marxism approach to International Relations, explain Essay

With respect to Marxism approach to foreign Relations, explain how theoretical debates within a particular theory service us to define more precisely how best to use IR theory in practice - Essay ExampleThis literature looks not alone at the ways economic system has impact on the relations between the states, but it tried to analyze how the ideational and ideological factors help economise and reinforce the legitimacy of the existing system through hegemony.In this paper, I would like to highlight the points of contention within Marxist approach in International Relations. First, I will outline the basic problems that are the center of the intra-paradigm debate in Marxism, from the Gramscian and Neo-Gramcian perspective. Second, I will bring the example of how the theoretical debates within Marxism go to differentiation in the analysis of contemporary international situation. Finally, based on the debates between Alex Callinicos and Kees van der Pijl this paper will conclude if there is an inherent contradiction in terms between the capitalist states or, as Neo-Granscianism claims, capitalist states, driven by the social forces represented by bourgeoisie elites, will come to consensus on the common maturation of the world-system.One of the basic concepts in Gramscis writings is hegemony. By hegemony, Gramsci meant the permeation throughout society of an entire system of values, attitudes, beliefs and morality (common sense) that has the effect of supporting the circumstance quo in power relations. Individual actors are not aware of the bigger picture simply because they are not capable of overcoming the routines of maintaining their living. (Boggs, 1976 121-122) Neo-Gramscianism applies this idea to the peripheral and semi-peripheral states in the capitalist world-system.Cox, criticizing Realist approach, argues that dominance by a powerful state may be a necessary but not a sufficient setting for hegemony. (Cox, 1981 139) He suggests that power can be exerted through ideas and institutions not less efficiently than through material capabilities of state.

No comments:

Post a Comment

Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.